Day 19 – Social Movements and Collective Action in India
Excellent, Rahul π
Here’s the original structured scheme for Day 19, as per your long-term sociology plan (continuing from Day 18B).
Day 19 – Social Movements and Collective Action in India
Theme:
Understanding the dynamics, theories, and transformations of social movements — from classical to contemporary — with special focus on India.
1. Core Areas of Study (4-Box Structure)
| Box 1: Conceptual Foundations | Box 2: Theories of Social Movements | Box 3: Major Social Movements in India | Box 4: Contemporary and Digital Movements |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meaning and typology of social movements; distinction between crowd, mob, revolution, and reform. | Classical theories (Marx, Smelser, Resource Mobilization, New Social Movement Theory, Touraine, Melucci). | Peasant, Dalit, Women’s, Environmental, and Tribal Movements; Regional Autonomy movements. | Farmers’ protests, anti-CAA movement, digital activism (#MeToo, #SaveAarey); intersection of social media and mobilization. |
2. Indian Theorists & Interpretive Frameworks
-
A. R. Desai: Marxist framework — movements as responses to class exploitation and state failure.
-
Ghanshyam Shah: “Social Movements in India: A Review of Literature” — classification into reformist, revolutionary, and revivalist.
-
M. S. A. Rao: Focus on peasant and agrarian mobilization — role of leadership and organization.
-
T. K. Oommen: Integrationist view — movements as processes of democratization and social inclusion.
-
Rajni Kothari: Political process approach — link between movements and democratic deepening.
-
Gail Omvedt: Feminist and Dalit perspectives — movements as struggles for dignity and identity, not just class.
3. Theoretical Anchors
| Theory | Core Idea | Critique / Indian Adaptation |
|---|---|---|
| Marxist | Movements emerge from contradictions of capitalism and class struggle. | Ignores caste & ethnicity; corrected by Dalit & tribal scholars. |
| Relative Deprivation (Smelser) | Frustration and gap between expectation and reality cause mobilization. | Explains some agrarian & reservation protests. |
| Resource Mobilization (McCarthy & Zald) | Leadership, organization, and networks determine success. | Fits Indian farmers’ movements & NGOs. |
| New Social Movements (Touraine, Melucci) | Focus on identity, culture, and post-materialist values. | Women’s and environmental movements in India. |
4. Key Indian Case Studies
| Type | Movement | Core Feature | Impact |
|---|---|---|---|
| Peasant | Telangana (1946–51), Naxalite, BKU, Farmers’ Protests (2020–21) | Agrarian inequality, state repression | Land reform debates, farm law repeal |
| Dalit | Ambedkarite Movement, Dalit Panthers | Assertion of dignity and rights | Political mobilization, rise of BSP |
| Tribal | Chipko, Jharkhand, Narmada Bachao Andolan | Ecological & livelihood rights | Forest rights act, regional identity |
| Women’s | Self-Employed Women’s Association (SEWA), #MeToo | Patriarchy, economic empowerment | Legal & social reforms |
| Environmental | Chipko, Appiko, Silent Valley | Ecological justice | Environmental awareness, policy shift |
5. Emerging Trends
-
Hybrid Movements: Online–offline synergy (e.g., anti-CAA, farmers’ protests).
-
Shift from Class to Identity: From economic grievances to dignity politics.
-
Media as Mobilizer: Hashtag activism, viral images, transnational solidarity.
-
NGOization: Institutionalization and depoliticization of movements.
-
State Response: Co-option, surveillance, or repression — defining modern “post-protest politics.”
6. Keywords & Concepts
Social movement • Mobilization • Framing • Identity politics • NGOization • Collective action • Repertoire of contention • Political opportunity structure • Counter-movement • Post-materialism
7. UPSC Previous Questions (2013–2024)
| Year | Question |
|---|---|
| 2013 | Discuss the role of ideology in social movements. |
| 2016 | Examine the role of caste and class in agrarian movements in India. |
| 2017 | “Social movements in India have shifted from class-based to identity-based.” Discuss. |
| 2019 | Analyze the impact of globalization on social movements in India. |
| 2020 | Discuss how media and technology have transformed the nature of collective action. |
| 2022 | “Women’s movements in India represent both continuity and change.” Explain. |
| 2023 | Examine the relationship between democracy and social movements in India. |
8. Reflective Integration
“Social movements are the laboratories of democracy — where the excluded negotiate their inclusion.”
In India, the evolution from class-based to identity-based and now digitally networked movements reflects the interplay of modernity, media, and political opportunity.
They challenge not just the state, but the imagination of equality itself.
Would you like me to now prepare Day 19B (Applied Analysis & Essay-Ready Notes) — showing how modern movements blend class, caste, gender, and media, with references to Desai, Omvedt, and Shah — similar to Day 18B’s structure?
Comments
Post a Comment